Amazon Fire TV Stick vs. Google Chromecast for Travel
How does the Amazon Fire TV Stick compare to the Google Chromecast for travel? If you are wondering which you should go pick as a travel stream stick, we break down each of their travel features. This includes how resilient it is with potentially inconsistent Hotel WiFi, some common problems and solutions you might need while away from home with your Roku.
We’ve recently recently tested a number of streaming sticks to determine which streaming devices are best for travel. If you are interested in knowing the other options available and how they compare, check out our Best Streaming Sticks for Travel.
Hotel/Airbnb WiFi Support
The Amazon Fire TV Stick generally works well on hotel or Airbnb WiFi. Unlike the Chromecast the Roku does not need any special configuration for each hotel. You just need to connect to the hotel’s WiFi. However, most hotel WiFi systems do have a captive portal. You can read more about that below.
What are captive portals? They are the popups you get that prompt you to login or provide additional information prior to using the Hotel, AirBnb or other locations WiFi. Captive portal are rarely used at most AirBnb’s. However, for regular hotel travelers they are a primary feature for sure. Very few hotels allow you to use their WiFi without accepting terms and conditions, entering a room name, an additional password screen or other consideration.
|Amazon Fire TV Stick
|The Amazon Fire TV Stick is actually the only streaming stick that truly supports captive portals. It will popup and allow you to use the remote to navigate and enter any information needed, which is usually room number and last name, on most captive portal screens.
|Google Chromecast does not support captive portals at all. However, if you connect with a phone or other device that does support captive portals and then configure the Chromecast, it can in some instances still use the connection, but it’s generally the exception. If you stay at a lot of hotels that use a captive portal, the Chromecast is not going to be a great choice.
A travel router can help you avoid this extra step. With a travel router once you pass the captive portal on one device, usually your phone or laptop, any additional devices you connect will work normally.
Automatic Remote Config
Something rarely discussed by non-travel sites is the automatic remote configuration feature of many streaming sticks. While at home setting up your remote is a one time need, at least until you buy a new TV. When traveling each new location has a new TV. If you want to be able to use a single remote to control the volume and power on your TV and your streaming stick, you’ll likely want a device that can automatically detect the TV.
For the devices that have this feature, all you need to do is connect via HDMI to a newer TV. Most TVs since 2016 support identification via HDMI that the supported devices can use to configure the remotes.
|Amazon Fire TV Stick
|The Amazon Fire TV Stick supports this feature. It will automatically detect the TV and control it’s volume and power features without needing to enter any codes or identify the TV model yourself.
|Since the Chromecast does not have a remote, it does not support this feature. You’ll need to continue to use the remote that came with the TV to control the volume.
In our recent comparison of Streaming Stick WiFi Performance, the Amazon Fire TV Stick performed very well. It essentially tied at the top of our performance list. Bottom line the Amazon device will be as capable as any other WiFi stick at dealing with inconsistent or poor hotel WiFi.
The Google Chromecast placed last. While the Chromecast is reasonably resilient to poor WiFi it degraded and stop working under half the conditions the Roku did. This does not necessarily make it a bad choice for travel. It’s low cost and the chance you may already have one mean it can still be a viable choice. However, if you are looking to purchase a dedicated streaming device for travel, you may want to consider some of the other players.
Common Problems and Solutions
Finding Power For Your Streaming Stick In A Hotel – Many hotel rooms don’t make it easy to find power sources for your streaming stick. Here are a few tips and tricks that may help you.
Changing Input On Hotel TVs – many hotel TVs don’t make it easy or obvious how to change the input on the TV. This guide will provide a few tips and tricks.